844 Gulf & Prime Claim this business
About
844 Gulf & Prime is a fine dining restaurant located in Marco Island. They offer seafood restaurant, american restaurant, bar and restaurant services. Rated 4.4 stars from 220 Google reviews.
Services
Send an Inquiry
Contact 844 Gulf & Prime directly for quotes or questions.
Is this your business?
Take control of your listing, respond to inquiries, and attract more local customers.
Claim this profileContact Info
- Address844 Bald Eagle Dr, Marco Island, FL 34145, USA, Marco Island 34145
- Phone(239) 544-9844
- Website844gulfandprime.com/
- $Pricing$$
Your ad here
Contact us to advertise in this spot
Reviews
We had a great experience at Gulf 844 Prime. We arrived before the dinner rush with reservations for a party of four, and everything from start to finish was excellent. The drinks alone are worth going for, so many well-crafted cocktails to choose from and all done really well. Service was friendly and attentive without feeling over the top, and the food was soooo good. My husband ordered the ribs and said they were the best he’s ever had, and my Chilean sea bass was fresh, perfectly prepared, and absolutely excellent. We’ve dined here before and will definitely be back again. It may feel a little expensive for some, but it’s absolutely worth it for the quality and overall experience.
We had dinner at 844 Gulf & Prime twice in the past 5 days. I would have been more but had some late golfing to do. We had a table for 4 and Jamie was out server. She, along with Henry the Sommelier treated us incredibly well. Our meals were impeccable and the Chateauneuf du pape Henry selected for us paired very well with our meals. For dessert we had the cheesecake which is not to be missed! 100% going back. 100% recommend! Cheers!
Update 1-22-26: Triple Tale was #1, Aged Ribeye Special #2, Dover Sole Table-side Special #3 and Veal Indorato #4 in our ranking but really they were all Excellent!!! Lychee Martini is excellent as is the Basque Style Cheesecake. Stellar service and atmosphere too! We highly recommend. My new favorite place! Excellent food, service and atmosphere. Huge bar if you want to just hang out there and eat. Dessert Martinis, Baked Alaska, Bread is wonderful, Scallops Augratin delicious as well as the TripleTail. Pablo was a very attentive server and didn't make us feel rushed.
Scallops turned out well. Our party got two ribeye steaks that were horrible. Likely the fattiest steaks we’ve ever had. Have purchased better steaks from the grocery store. They did a good job trying to upsell to a “better” steak for $120. For $65, I would not exect a grocery store quality steak. Will not be going back. never would I expect a steak of that horrible quality. Be aware, the service is really slow and the steaks are really fatty. If you like scallops, those were good, but it's not an experience saver. Be aware, you've been warned. If you're thinking about steaks, there are far better options on the island. Truly disappointing.
Server Jimena was fantastic. Very attentive. The food was delicious too. Atmosphere really good too. It was a bit noisy due to other parties, but I reckon that's not their doing. People was just loud that day I guess. It's a very nice place . 100% recommend .